miami-imc
Home About Us Contact Us Radio Print Video Calendar
Translate

Search the Site


All the Newswires
Florida IMCs
About Indymedia

Indymedia Projects
INDYMEDIA NETWORK
printable version - email this article

View article without comments

Why Do People Loot?
by Amanda Ripley Saturday, Mar. 06, 2010 at 2:09 AM

What is looting? Is it the taking of property after a disaster? If so, then was it looting when some World Trade Center evacuees on 9/11 broke into soda machines and distributed water to people in the stairways? What about when civilians took water trucks in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and drove around neighborhoods distributing clean water? Where is the line?

Why Do People Loot?...
gal_chile_earthquake_8.jpg, image/jpeg, 575x320

I watched all the Chile “looting” footage I could find yesterday. It was hard to know what I was looking at, as it always is when you are watching disasters from afar--and often even when you are right there. I mostly saw people carrying water, diapers, sacks of flour and other necessities. I saw young men playing Robin Hood, throwing paper towels and toilet paper rolls from storefront balconies to older women waiting, arms uplifted, below.

Not to say that these people are wrong--or right. Just to say, I don’t know either way. I do think looting is happening, but it is equally clear that the reporting of the looting is somewhat more righteous than it probably should be.

What is looting? Is it the taking of property after a disaster? If so, then was it looting when some World Trade Center evacuees on 9/11 broke into soda machines and distributed water to people in the stairways? What about when civilians took water trucks in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and drove around neighborhoods distributing clean water? Where is the line?

The one consensus seems to be what I call the “plasma TV test.” If people are taking TVs, then that, we can all agree, is probably looting. Especially if they are fancy TVs! You see this pattern after most big disasters. First comes the catastrophe, then comes TV people talking about the generalized fear of looting--then comes a strange and disconcerting looting montage: footage of people carrying groceries out of stores, hearsay about violence and, finally, reports of stolen plasma TVs.

Here is one of the many plasma-TV stories to come out of Chile. (Notice the photo, which features a disheveled and frightened young man carrying...diapers.)

As I’ve written before, looting reports usually turn out to be exaggerated after most disasters. Looting happens, and it is damaging to the relief effort and the social fabric, but it rarely represents more than a drop in the bucket compared to the damage inflicted by the disaster itself.

As Ilan smartly pointed out in a comment to the previous post, we just don’t know much about disaster looting. What we do know is mostly from the U.S., which may or may not be relevant in this case. The scant research that has been done outside the U.S. suggests that it only happens in a major way when three other pre-existing conditions are met:

1. Dramatic disparity between rich and poor.
2. High levels of petty crime and gang activity.
3. An ineffective and corrupt police force.

We will one day (hopefully) get better information about what happened in the streets after Chile’s earthquake. Until then, my strategy is to listen to all the reports I hear with one question in the back of my mind: “How do you know that?” In other words, did you see it?

For example, when reading this Washington Post story today (which also includes the plasma TV claim. Check!), I had to wonder about this line:

“...the pillaging was carried out largely by poorer Chileans.”

Really? How do you know? Did you do a random sampling of the pillagers and survey them about their income levels? Or are you making that conclusion based on how the 27 looters you saw looked--what they were wearing, how they spoke, etc.? Either way is OK, but I’d love to know.


add your comments


Looting?
by Amanda Ripley Saturday, Mar. 06, 2010 at 2:09 AM

Looting?...
gal_chile_earthquake_10.jpg, image/jpeg, 337x475


add your comments


WTF is the problem?
by A Saturday, Mar. 06, 2010 at 2:39 PM

I just don't understand what is wrong with people taking whatever they want from stores and shops. Especially after a natural disaster.

The most disgusting thing is when police and army shoot people for taking material things, UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. No material object is worth a single human life, period.

What if it was ok to 'loot?' What if people took what they needed, whenever they needed it? The 'breakdown of social order?' Great! It's about time to breakdown a 'social order' that relegates the majority to poverty and allows a few to live in luxury. People should loot every day.


add your comments


Hardy stay the principal
by liza Wednesday, Apr. 20, 2011 at 1:16 AM
amo1314521@gmail.com 15956957321 anhui hefei

The thought grabbing tattoos from Hardy stay the principal attraction in the special ed hardy Hardy jeans for men. pandora jewelry The brand brand is constantly developing in appeal, attracting millions of grownup males and ladies every and every year. pandora the best place could possibly be the actuality that these jeans are priced really reasonably, pandora beads which most in the purchasers can spend to possess this sort of the exclusive pair. ed hardy online shop Owing to Christian's work to market the jeans straight in the direction of celebrities, they are ordinarily observed placing on special ed hardy Hardy jeans every and every now and then. replica chanel The clothing stores of Hardy are positioned in huge profile areas in which the celebrities ordinarily would rather shop.


add your comments


ray ban 3025 aviators
by ray ban 3025 aviators Wednesday, May. 11, 2011 at 9:36 PM
SilasPhanor@gmail.com 2345678910 NY

The ray ban 3025 aviators Spectacle grow into favorable models to select from in some of the ray ban 3350 eyeglass concept. Influenced inside the 3025 ray ban Ray-ban Wayfarer sunglass conception , now this solution rb 3025 eyeglasses is a great assortment reveal eat several particular attention. Typically the eyeglass frames for these 3025 ray ban aviators Ray-ban Rx wayfarer reading glasses are produce of unbelievably extended high-quality cellophane.


add your comments


Miami IMC Newswires
Upcoming Events
No events have been posted for this week.
All Recent Articles
Article Photo Video Audio
M17 7:39PM
El sueño americano (video)
M17 5:30PM
Congress has VIOLATED the First Amendment of the US Constitution and Establi$hed Religion!
M17 12:17PM
U.S. Election 2012: Alexander says Republicans Can’t Win against Obama
M17 9:44AM
Developing a New Economic System
M16 1:37PM
Video: Joshua Holland "The 15 Biggest Lies About the Economy"
M16 8:08AM
Israel ataca a un buque con ayuda a Gaza en aguas internacionales
M16 5:54AM
Solidaridad con Cuba desde Miami
M15 9:33AM
BTL:Although National Media Spotlight is Gone, Progressive Mobilization Against Wis. Gov.
M15 7:46AM
La Historia Sionista (video)
M14 8:14PM
U.S. House of Representatives: Stupid? Crooks? or Stupid Crooks?
M14 4:38PM
LIMPIEZA ETNICA DE LOS PALESTINOS
M14 1:33PM
BTL:For Fatah, New Unity Pact with Hamas is Risky, but Few Options Remained
M13 2:08PM
Thomas Paine and Noam Chomsky
M13 8:08AM
BTL:Claims that U.S. Torture Played Key Role in Locating Osama bin Laden are Unsupportable
M11 12:46PM
Osama bin Laden killed by US Forces/No Justice without a trial
M10 6:29PM
Amtrak Officials Back Schumer's Proposal For No Ride List (1) Comments
M10 6:23PM
Obama is accomplice to GW Bush regime's war crimes
M09 8:09PM
EL GOLPE DE ESTADO DE LOS BANCOS (Video)
M09 5:49PM
Chuck Schumer (D) Calls for Train Station Gestapo Zones
M09 7:31AM
BTL:Nuclear Adviser Resigns over Japanese Government's Increasing Level of Allowable Radia
M08 6:53PM
~ WHEN 666 BECAME KARL ROVES CALLING CARD INTO THE U.S. SUPREME COURT ~ (1) Comments
M08 11:07AM
VIDEO: Las guerras que Ud no ve
M08 9:26AM
BTL:NOW: GOP Assault on Middle Class is a 'War on Women'
M08 8:47AM
Wage revolutionary struggle to put an end to the spiral of terrorist violence
M07 5:31PM
El Parlamento Europeo recibira a la Flotilla Rumbo a Gaza
M07 1:55PM
U.S. Election 2012- Stewart Alexander Says Obama Could Lose in 2012
M07 8:58AM
BTL:How Will Bin Laden's Death Affect the U.S. War in Afghanistan?
M06 5:12AM
La censura a Hortensia Morán y el código de ética de Fernando Lugo
M06 1:05AM
Thousands of militant workers march for higher pay in the Philippines
M05 7:11PM
La segunda muerte de Bin Laden?
M04 11:24PM
Join the International Solidarity Mvement
M04 5:35PM
Iranian Muslim Divorce in USA
M04 9:57AM
Gaza demonstrators condemn death of bin Laden
M04 9:42AM
AMERICAN EXPRESS BEATS BACK ISRAEL BOYCOTTERS
M03 9:49PM
Hortensia Morán lanzará su libro sobre Fernando Lugo en Fernando de la Mora
M03 5:45PM
Mountain Justice Training Camp May 20-27 Letcher County, Kentucky www.mountainjustice.org
M02 9:07PM
Cuba: No están sol@s
M01 2:57PM
U.S. PR Firm on Payroll of Qatari Group that Took Part in Gaza Flotilla
M01 2:44PM
Divestment defeated at UC San Diego
M01 9:39AM
BTL:Economic and Political Power of Oil Industry Succeeds in Weakening Deep Water Drilling
Older Newswire Posts
View Hidden Posts


© 2003-2009 Miami Independent Media Center. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by the Miami Independent Media Center. Running sf-active v0.9.2 Disclaimer | Privacy