miami-imc
Home About Us Contact Us Radio Print Video Calendar
Translate

Search the Site


All the Newswires
Florida IMCs
About Indymedia

Indymedia Projects
INDYMEDIA NETWORK
printable version - email this article

Limits of Private Property
by Stephan Schilling Saturday, May. 10, 2008 at 8:35 AM
mbatko@lycos.com (email address validated)

If life does not consist in the abundance of things and time is borrowed from the future, do possessions invalidate community? Is life colonized by "instrumental rationality" (Habermas) when all dialogue and relations are dominated by money?

LIMITS OF PRIVATE PROPERTY

By Stephan Schilling

[This article published in: Attac Rundbrief 1/08 is translated from the German on the World Wide Web, http://www.attac.de.]




Global capitalism in its current form is increasingly losing legitimacy. Uneasiness grows over the economic model that produces gigantic riches for a minority and social exclusion for more and more people and leads directly to climate catastrophe. Opinion polls on these upheavals and the end of neoliberal hegemony show the shift of political discourse. Social justice and protection of the atmosphere are increasingly serious themes in the debates over minimum wage and in the pleas of the SPD (Social-Democratic party in Germany) and the Greens for credible initiatives in social policy.

The chance of taking a further step in delegitimating the present economic order lies in these changes. Who owns what and what can he do with his possession? These are basic questions to our economic order that we thematicize with the property question and with pat Attac demands like the Tobin tax and just world trade. The property question resonates in the slogan of the World Social Forum of Porto Allegre “The World is not a Commodity.” Now we have the chance to intensify this and make it more explicit.

Consistent alternatives to the existing economic model are rarely presented across the political spectrum by communists or advocates of a socially and ecologically regulated mixed economy. Together we should thematicize the question about the limits of private property. Criticism of accumulation of vast financial assets in the hands of a few that has no legitimation before the backdrop of the poverty of so many and criticism of the growing commercialization of all areas of life and the artificial creation of intellectual property are part of this challenge. We should also ask what owners can legitimately do with their property. Shutting down profitable enterprises to fulfill double-digit profit expectations is certainly not part of this.

CONCRETIZING THE PROPERTY QUESTION

The campaign for the democratic control of electricity companies makes clear the meaning of the property question. With their enormous economic power, four mammoth companies block all efforts at protecting the atmosphere as the construction of 24 new coal power plants proves. The quest for double-digit profits causes electricity prices to rise brutally despite stagnating wages. This is ultimately a massive redistribution from bottom to the top. Thus it is time to raise the property question. Attac’s electricity campaign will explicitly demand dismantling the four conglomerates and their conversion to public property. Without forgetting that Moloch-like state companies like Vattenfall or the French electricity company EDF are not solutions, decentralized businesses that make possible real democratic control are crucial.

Another theme is the current pseudo-debate around managers’ top salaries. The problem is the tremendous profit expectations of owners of capital leading to massive redistribution from wage income to capital income, not the top salaries of managers. 600,000 millionaires live in Germany. Four percent of households possess 1.3 trillion euro of financial assets. The remaining 96 percent own 2.4 trillion euro. 13.5 percent own either nothing or debts. Raising the property question is vital, instead of politically accelerating the process through tax cuts as in the past. [Translator’s note: 1% of the US population have 95% of the assets in our soft-feudalism!]

Such debates will make clear: The time is right to break open a new chapter in the delegitimation of an economic model that brings on social and ecological crises. Attac is the right actor to seriously begin this new chapter.

[Important articles on global justice, anti-militarism, political theory and economic ethics are offered at http://www.attac.de and http://www.attac.at.]


add your comments


Miami IMC Newswires
Upcoming Events
No events have been posted for this week.
All Recent Articles
Article Photo Video Audio
N25 4:40PM
bARACK oBAMA NO PRIORIZO LA DEMOCRACIA
N24 4:01PM
Democraticamente. Fernando Lugo, el impeachment y la proyección del golpismo
N24 3:14AM
Zhibin Gu: Chinese multinationals vs global financial crisis: outsourcing, jobs, politics
N24 2:10AM
Health Bill Ignores Industrial Health Harms
N23 5:20PM
Solidarity with the UC Student Protests; Education is our right!
N23 1:46PM
CUBANUESTRA. LA KAKISTOCRACIA DE FERNANDO LUGO
N23 9:20AM
VIDEO and transcript: Nomi Prins' "It Takes a Pillage"
N22 6:06PM
where will it end
N21 9:28AM
PFP Gubernatorial Candidate Alexander Condemns UC Tuition Hikes
N21 8:52AM
El Judaismo, un invento
N20 12:40PM
Sobre Boicot a Flor de Caña y la IRC: CST rechaza iniciativa antiobrera
N20 11:44AM
N20 11:04AM
BTL:Protests in 19th Year Demand Closure of U.S. Military School for Latin American Soldie
N20 8:18AM
El racismo criminal de rabinos en Israel
N20 6:55AM
FERNANDO LUGO: EL MORALISTA VIOLADOR Y SECUESTRADOR
N20 5:16AM
Zhibin Gu: globalization map: China, India, and next stage world politics, finance, leader
N19 2:24PM
La virgen de guadalupe y los curas
N19 9:31AM
BTL:Obama Breaks with Latin America on Overturning Honduran Coup
N19 9:23AM
The Dominance of the Financial Sector is a Mortal Danger
N18 4:01PM
CUBANUESTRA. NEGOCIADO CON TIERRAS, DE CONSTANTINO Y SILVESTRE I A FERNANDO LUGO
N17 5:32PM
El partido como antítesis de la Revolución (o el anacronismo de las sectas-partido)
N17 4:24PM
La crisis financiera explicada de forma sencilla
N17 11:49AM
A Year of Obama
N17 2:48AM
Zhibin Gu: China outsourcing, tech, stock market, management lessons
N16 6:08PM
Honduras. El Imperio contraataca
N16 4:05PM
Free "Plan B: 4.0. Mobilizing to Save Civilization"
N16 3:54PM
Good and Bad Choices for Energy Policy and the Environmental Movement 2009-2010
N16 10:19AM
AUNG SAN SUU KYI, OMAR KHADR, AND BARACK OBAMA: A DREADFUL TALE OF WHAT AMERICA HAS BECOME
N16 3:37AM
Tour various Vault Sites and the Hemet facility
N16 3:36AM
The Hubbard Is Bare
N15 9:16AM
BTL:Media Spins Nov. 3rd GOP Victories as "Change Election"
N15 6:59AM
DIARIO SIGLO XXI. ZUNY CASTIÑEIRA, LA MUSA INSPIRADORA DE FERNANDO LUGO Y LÓPEZ PERITO
N14 1:31PM
Tasar la especulación financiera
N13 7:46PM
Anti-Fascist Hackers Destroy Holocaust Denier David Irving's Website
N13 3:07PM
Over 300 Homeless People Expected to Participate: Informational Picketing @ Rivers Casino
N13 12:58PM
Alexander: Gov. Schwarzenegger Should Investigate A.G. Jerry Brown’s Office
N13 8:51AM
BTL:Pro Choice Groups Declare War on Anti-Abortion Amendment in Healthcare Bill
N13 1:05AM
Zhibin Gu: China's corruption vs modern politics, economy, finance and globa financial cri
N12 11:58PM
The Team is Real
N12 7:25PM
En defensa del ateismo, la discusión y el pensamiento libre
Older Newswire Posts
View Hidden Posts


© 2003-2009 Miami Independent Media Center. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by the Miami Independent Media Center. Running sf-active v0.9.2 Disclaimer | Privacy